- Joined
- Apr 29, 2025
- Messages
- 17
- Thread Author
- #1
A5wagyuK
Petitioner
v.
Ministry of Justice
Respondent
Petitioner
v.
Ministry of Justice
Respondent
I. Jurisdictional Statement
This Court has jurisdiction over appeals for criminal misdemeanor offenses under Alex. Const. Part III, Sec. 16, as well as Sec. 3 Sub. Sec. 3 of the Alexandria Criminal Code ("ACC").
II. Factual Circumstances
- On May 17, 2025, Extromondo and fearlessNacktmul engaged in a property dispute which eventually led to a fight.
- A5wagyuK noticed there was a dispute, and made his way over to the property.
- When he arrived, he saw Extromondo and fearlessNacktmul attacking and killing each other multiple times.
- Extromondo was warned to leave the property, but did not leave.
- When A5wagyuK noticed that Extromondo was on fearlessNacktmul property attacking him, he intervened to defend fearlessNacktmul.
- All parties engaged in fighting for an extended 20 minutes, at which point fighting ceased.
- On May 20, 2025, Snow_crp fined A5wagyuK $4200
- A5WagyuK engaged in self-defense of another when he defended fearlessNacktmul from attacks by Extromondo. See ACC Sec. 4, Sub. Sec. 2.
- At the time, it was reasonable for A5WagyuK to believe that fearlessNacktmul was in danger of death from the illegal and dangerous actions of Extromondo.
- Additionally, A5WagyuK was protected by castle doctrine as Extromondo had been told to leave once previously. See ACC Sec. 3, Sub. Sec. 11.
- The right to defend himself extended to A5WagyuK from fearlessNacktmul, as A5WagyuK fought on behalf of fearlessNacktmul.
- Because A5WagyuK's actions were lawful on the 17th, this Court should under its appellate powers from the ACC reverse the summary decision of the Ministry of Justice Officer.
Therefore, petitioner requests this Court reverse the determination of the Ministry of Justice Officer, and return the $4200 fined from A5WagyuK. Additionally, the Ministry of Justice should be made to pay for the legal fees incurred from this appeal, which amount to $100.
Witness List:
A5WagyuK
Extromondo
fearlessNacktmul
Snow_crp