Lawsuit: Dismissed Crown v. Muggy21 , Case 21 (Mag. Ct., 2025)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Your honour this has gone on for long enough. Citizens deserve the right to a speedy trial.
 
I hereby find the government in Contempt. They shall be fined £100.

@Dearev I once again order you to assign a public defender to this case. For each twenty-four hours you fail to do so, I shall double the previous fine against the government.
 
Good day, forgive me for a late appearance as i had not received a notification regarding this case.
 
Your honor, The public defender program requests a 24 hour extension due to we being in the process of migrating the public defenders office from the MoW to its independent entity.
 
AmityBlamity said:
Granted.
Click to expand...
your honor we apologize but we will need another extension, migration has been an extensive thing and it is yet to be finished, the PD program promisses this court that this will be the last asked extension for 24 hours.
 
Dearev said:
your honor we apologize but we will need another extension, migration has been an extensive thing and it is yet to be finished, the PD program promisses this court that this will be the last asked extension for 24 hours.
Click to expand...
Granted.
 
IN THE MAGISTRATE COURT OF THE KINGDOM OF ALEXANDRIA
Answer to Criminal Complaint

I. Plea​

The defendant pleads NOT GUILTY on both charges:

1. Murder — NOT GUILTY
2. Obstruction of Justice — NOT GUILTY

II. Facts​

The defendant
1. Affirms, that Chat recorded: “Muggy21 has started the fight, you can legally defend yourself!” immediately followed by “999 Muggy21 has murdered you!” at the time of incident.

2. Affirms, that Physical forensic evidence in the form of a Blood Splatter was recovered at the scene, confirming:
Victim: Nimq_
Time: 10/22/2025 00:24:18
Attacker: Muggy21 (100% confirmed)

3. Denies, that Chat and game log documentation show the initiation of an unprovoked assault by the defendant.

4. Affirms, that The defendant subsequently logged off while in handcuffs during detainment, but denies, that [the defendant was] obstructing lawful processing and jailing procedures. And, that This behavior indicates mens rea (intent) and knowledge of guilt.

III. Defense​

Your honour,
Murder underlays the following definition within the Criminal Code and Procedure Act §21(2)(a):
Murder - A player is guilty of murder if they intentionally and knowingly or with extreme recklessness kill another player without consent from the other them.
The Crown fails to deliver any evidence that proves our client has intentionally killed Nimq or acted with extreme recklessness. The message "999 Muggy21 has murdered you!" uses "murdered" as a synonym for "killed", the plug-in is unable to interpret the intent or recklessness. We therefore believe that the evidence leaves a reasonable doubt that our client has intentionally and knowingly killed Nimq. A conviction of our client, despite this reasonable doubt left, would be unjustified.

On the charge of Obstruction of Justice:
Obstruction of Justice underlays the following definition within the Criminal Code and Procedure Act §20(7)(a):
Obstruction of Justice - A player is guilty of obstruction of justice if they willfully and deliberately act in a manner which hinders the apprehension, conviction, defense, or punishment of any player.
When trying to use this section on the case we must keep attention to the details, especially to the word "apprehension". Apprehension is the act of arresting or detaining someone, not the act of holding someone in arrest or detention. Our client escaped the detention, as the Crown affirms in fact 4 in the first part-sentence (until the comma (,)). He has already been detained when he escaped, the apprehension has already happened and did not get hindered. Escaping detention is fully legal according to id. at. §20(7)(a).

IV. Submission​

The Defendant respectfully submits this answer to the Criminal Complaint to the Magistrate Court of the Kingdom of Alexandria.

The Public Defender Programs apologizes for these long delays and the late response. I will now continue to represent the defendant, as deputized to by the Chief Public Defender.
 
Last edited:
IN THE MAGISTRATE COURT OF THE KINGDOM OF ALEXANDRIA
Amendment to Answer to Criminal Complaint

Your honour,
it seems like I got some things mixed up within the defense.
I would like to enter the following amendment, if allowed:

Part III is amended in the following manner:
"Apprehension is the act of arresting or detaining someone, not the act of being held holding someone in arrest or detention."
 
CoolCat said:
IN THE MAGISTRATE COURT OF THE KINGDOM OF ALEXANDRIA
Amendment to Answer to Criminal Complaint

Your honour,
it seems like I got some things mixed up within the defense.
I would like to enter the following amendment, if allowed:

Part III is amended in the following manner:
"Apprehension is the act of arresting or detaining someone, not the act of being held holding someone in arrest or detention."
Click to expand...
Granted.
 
IN THE MAGISTRATE COURT OF THE KINGDOM OF ALEXANDRIA
ENTREATY TO NOLLE PROSEQUI

Your Honor,

The Ministry of Justice has sided against continuing prosecution against the Defendant, as further pursuit of this charge serves neither justice nor the public interest. Citizens should not be made to endure months of proceedings based on a single murder charge.

Accordingly, the Crown requests this Court to accept our decision to nolle prosequi all charges against the Defendant.

Respectfully submitted,

Soggeh T. Oast
Minister of Justice
KIngdom of Alexandria
 
SoggehToast said:
IN THE MAGISTRATE COURT OF THE KINGDOM OF ALEXANDRIA
ENTREATY TO NOLLE PROSEQUI

Your Honor,

The Ministry of Justice has sided against continuing prosecution against the Defendant, as further pursuit of this charge serves neither justice nor the public interest. Citizens should not be made to endure months of proceedings based on a single murder charge.

Accordingly, the Crown requests this Court to accept our decision to nolle prosequi all charges against the Defendant.

Respectfully submitted,

Soggeh T. Oast
Minister of Justice
KIngdom of Alexandria
Click to expand...
Granted.

The matter of Crown v. Muggy21 , Case 21 (Mag. Ct., 2025) is hereby dismissed with prejudice. The court thanks all involved.

So ordered,
Magistrate AmityBlamity
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top