Lawsuit: Adjourned Thritystone v. Crown, Case 6 (Mag. Ct., 2026)

IN THE HONOURABLE MAGISTRATE OF THE KINGDOM OF ALEXANDRIA
CRIMINAL ACTION
Case No.:
6
ENTREATY OF STRIKING AND ADMONISHING

Your Honor,

The Defense moves that the Court strikes Noble PhillinDeBlanc's answer to questions #9 and #10 due to being non-responsive, and that the Court directs him to answer the questions.

In Question #9, The plugin has nothing to do with the question that was asked of the witness, which was how did he personally make the determination at the defendant's arrest that it was murder and not something else.

In Question #10, the Defense did not ask what the wanted star shows. The witness was asked if a wanted star for sure, and without a reasonable doubt, meets the legal definition and burden of proof of a murder.

If the witness does not know or is unsure of the answers to these specific questions and the complexities involved, the Defense is okay with hearing "I do not know" as an answer instead of irrelevant testimony.

The Defense also humbly requests that the Court officially admonish the Noble Constable as a particular individual for being non-responsive to multiple questions being asked of him both now and previously, as he is now starting to waste both the Defense's and the Court's time.


Submitted Respectfully,

∴ ⨿🝛
The Artist Formerly Known as ConsequencesInc
5/25/2026
This entreaty is denied in its entirety. Writs of striking are specifically pertaining either to objectionable content or frivolous/scandalous portions of a pleading, claim, or defence. The legal concept of "non-responsive," born of Redmontian law, does not exist in the Kingdom of Alexandria.

Further, this court finds compelling the defences posed by the Crown. Both questions were answered, if perhaps ambiguously.

So ordered,
Magistrate Dogeington
 
IN THE HONOURABLE MAGISTRATE OF THE KINGDOM OF ALEXANDRIA
CRIMINAL ACTION
Case No.:
6
ENTREATY FOR IMMUNITY




Your honor,

While the witnesses does have his right to remain silent, I believe that there are options for the Court to consider.

The witnesses' right to not self-incriminate is important, and his testimony on these questions will also be important to determining my client's innocence. I think this is the best way to ensure the witness still can testify today.

I move that the Court request that the Crown grants the witness transactional immunity so that the he cannot be charged with a crime related to his conduct during Thritystone's arrest, and that if the Crown refuses that the Court grant the witness derivative use immunity so that his testimony in response to these questions cannot be used as evidence against him.


Submitted Respectfully,

∴ ⨿🝛
The Artist Formerly Known as ConsequencesInc
5/331/2026
This entreaty is denied.
It is unclear if the judiciary, let alone the Magistrates Court, has the authority to grant a witness immunity. Prosecutorial discretion is given to the MOJ. The best the court could do is ask the MOJ, to which they could say no, after which the court would have no recourse. In order to maintain the decorum of this court, I will not request that the MOJ grant immunity to PhillinDeBlanc.

It is PhillinDeBlanc's right to not produce self-incriminating evidence.
 
IN THE HONOURABLE MAGISTRATE OF THE KINGDOM OF ALEXANDRIA
CRIMINAL ACTION
Case No.:
6
ENTREATY TO INTRODUCE IMPEACHMENT EVIDENCE


Your honor,

Given the Noble PhillinDeBlanc's answer to question 8 posed to him, the Defense wishes to introduce impeachment evidence at this time that directly contradicts the witness' sworn statement. The Defense will wait for a response from the Crown and the Court's ruling before presenting it.


Submitted Respectfully,

∴ ⨿🝛
The Artist Formerly Known as ConsequencesInc
5/331/2026
@SoggehToast
You have 48 hours to respond.
 
IN THE MAGISTRATES COURT OF THE KINGDOM OF ALEXANDRIA
RESPONSE TO ENTREATY TO INTRODUCE IMPEACHMENT EVIDENCE


Your Honor,

The Crown is skeptical of this request based on A.P.04-019 §16(2). It is unclear whether impeachment evidence is an exception to this rule.

Respectfully submitted,

Soggeh T. Oast
Deputy Prime Minister
Kingdom of Alexandria
 
IN THE HONOURABLE MAGISTRATE OF THE KINGDOM OF ALEXANDRIA
CRIMINAL ACTION
Case No.:
6
ENTREATY TO INTRODUCE IMPEACHMENT EVIDENCE


Your honor,

Given the Noble PhillinDeBlanc's answer to question 8 posed to him, the Defense wishes to introduce impeachment evidence at this time that directly contradicts the witness' sworn statement. The Defense will wait for a response from the Crown and the Court's ruling before presenting it.


Submitted Respectfully,

∴ ⨿🝛
The Artist Formerly Known as ConsequencesInc
5/331/2026
Denied. Discovery has passed
 
IN THE HONOURABLE MAGISTRATE OF THE KINGDOM OF ALEXANDRIA
CRIMINAL ACTION
Case No.:
6
FOLLOW-UP QUESTIONS

Apologies to the court, I do have some follow up questions.


@Capt11543

9. You previously mentioned in your answer to Question 4 that you remember typing "some chat messages" to the Defendant. How did the conversation continue after you asked him if he knew how you managed to destroy the block?


@PhillinDeBlanc

Before I ask these questions, I wish to state the following for the court:

The incident in question of this trial occurred on April 8th, 2026, which was 67 days ago as of this posting. Under the Statute of Limitations Act, no party can start the pursuit of a summary or indictable criminal offense, or a civil action for something that happened more than 60 days ago. See §4-5 A.P. 01-007. This means that there is currently no threat of the witnesses 5th rights being violated.

Therefore, I will ask the Noble Peace Officer once again, while under oath:

16. Is it your testimony here today that you did not notify and identify to the Defendant that you were a police officer before you cuffed him?

17. Did you ever notify and identify yourself as a police officer to the Defendant between the time that you cuffed him and when he escaped from your hand cuffs?
 
IN THE HONOURABLE MAGISTRATE OF THE KINGDOM OF ALEXANDRIA
CRIMINAL ACTION
Case No.:
6
FOLLOW-UP QUESTIONS

Apologies to the court, I do have some follow up questions.


@Capt11543

9. You previously mentioned in your answer to Question 4 that you remember typing "some chat messages" to the Defendant. How did the conversation continue after you asked him if he knew how you managed to destroy the block?


@PhillinDeBlanc

Before I ask these questions, I wish to state the following for the court:

The incident in question of this trial occurred on April 8th, 2026, which was 67 days ago as of this posting. Under the Statute of Limitations Act, no party can start the pursuit of a summary or indictable criminal offense, or a civil action for something that happened more than 60 days ago. See §4-5 A.P. 01-007. This means that there is currently no threat of the witnesses 5th rights being violated.

Therefore, I will ask the Noble Peace Officer once again, while under oath:

16. Is it your testimony here today that you did not notify and identify to the Defendant that you were a police officer before you cuffed him?

17. Did you ever notify and identify yourself as a police officer to the Defendant between the time that you cuffed him and when he escaped from your hand cuffs?

16. 5th. (I do not think it is wise for me to take legal advice from an adversarial legal representative if the Honourable @Dogeington wishes to provide clarity on the matter, it would be greatly appreciated.)

17. 5th (I do not think it is wise for me to take legal advice from an adversarial legal representative, if the Honourable @Dogeington wishes to provide clarity on the matter, it would be greatly appreciated.)
 
Last edited:
Good morning (or whatever it is for you)! I'll be the presiding officer on this case. The Court has concerns over the counsel for both parties in this case, that being the current Prime Minister representing the Defendant, Thritystone, and a Magistrate representing the Crown. The Court grants the parties 72 hours for new counsel or explain why this isn't a problem.

cc: @ConsequencesInc @Thritystone @SoggehToast @bloodyrebals
 
IN THE HONOURABLE MAGISTRATE OF THE KINGDOM OF ALEXANDRIA
CRIMINAL ACTION
Case No.:
6
ENTREATY FOR JUDGEMENT ON THE PLEADINGS


Your honor,

Given the long delays in the case and the many changes that can happen when a case flounders for over a half a year, this is an unfortunate circumstance we have to work through.

For the sake of transparency, avoiding any further Conflicts of Interest that comes with the fact of the now-complicated issue of the many faces of ConsequencesInc and the new roles off other individuals originally in the trial, I move for a Judgement on the Pleadings.

This unique request differs from a Summary Judgement in that there is a genuine dispute of fact, as well as a Default Judgement in that it's the opinion of the Crown that this case be seen through to the end for fairness.

A Judgement on the Pleadings requests that the presiding officer take into account what has already occurred in this case, and as a trier of fact make a final ruling and determination.

Normally, this wouldn't be needed. Here, I think it is. This is a unique situation where I believe the Court is the only dis-interested party left insofar as it is probably the only one capable of rendering a fair and just verdict without accusations of political shenanigans or chicanery.

If ∴ ⨿🝛 representing the Plaintiff makes a move, people will accuse PM Sir Wigglesworth C. Shimmerclutch and Solicitor General Stephen W. Spooner, Jr. of corruption and collusion. And vice versa for whatever the aforementioned latter of the particular individuals do.


Submitted Respectfully,

∴ ⨿🝛
The Artist Formerly Known as ConsequencesInc
11/04/2026
 
IN THE HONOURABLE MAGISTRATE OF THE KINGDOM OF ALEXANDRIA
CRIMINAL ACTION
Case No.:
6
ENTREATY FOR JUDGEMENT ON THE PLEADINGS


Your honor,

Given the long delays in the case and the many changes that can happen when a case flounders for over a half a year, this is an unfortunate circumstance we have to work through.

For the sake of transparency, avoiding any further Conflicts of Interest that comes with the fact of the now-complicated issue of the many faces of ConsequencesInc and the new roles off other individuals originally in the trial, I move for a Judgement on the Pleadings.

This unique request differs from a Summary Judgement in that there is a genuine dispute of fact, as well as a Default Judgement in that it's the opinion of the Crown that this case be seen through to the end for fairness.

A Judgement on the Pleadings requests that the presiding officer take into account what has already occurred in this case, and as a trier of fact make a final ruling and determination.

Normally, this wouldn't be needed. Here, I think it is. This is a unique situation where I believe the Court is the only dis-interested party left insofar as it is probably the only one capable of rendering a fair and just verdict without accusations of political shenanigans or chicanery.

If ∴ ⨿🝛 representing the Plaintiff makes a move, people will accuse PM Sir Wigglesworth C. Shimmerclutch and Solicitor General Stephen W. Spooner, Jr. of corruption and collusion. And vice versa for whatever the aforementioned latter of the particular individuals do.


Submitted Respectfully,

∴ ⨿🝛
The Artist Formerly Known as ConsequencesInc
11/04/2026
Does the Crown (MoJ) or the Defendant oppose? Please respond within 48 hours.
 
IN THE MAGISTRATES COURT OF THE KINGDOM OF ALEXANDRIA
CRIMINAL ACTION
CASE NO: 6
RESPONSE TO COURT ORDER & ENTREATY FOR JUDGEMENT ON THE PLEADINGS


Good morning (or whatever it is for you)! I'll be the presiding officer on this case. The Court has concerns over the counsel for both parties in this case, that being the current Prime Minister representing the Defendant, Thritystone, and a Magistrate representing the Crown. The Court grants the parties 72 hours for new counsel or explain why this isn't a problem.

cc: @ConsequencesInc @Thritystone @SoggehToast @bloodyrebals

Your Honor, I will be representing the Crown in this matter.

IN THE HONOURABLE MAGISTRATE OF THE KINGDOM OF ALEXANDRIA
CRIMINAL ACTION
Case No.:
6
ENTREATY FOR JUDGEMENT ON THE PLEADINGS


Your honor,

Given the long delays in the case and the many changes that can happen when a case flounders for over a half a year, this is an unfortunate circumstance we have to work through.

For the sake of transparency, avoiding any further Conflicts of Interest that comes with the fact of the now-complicated issue of the many faces of ConsequencesInc and the new roles off other individuals originally in the trial, I move for a Judgement on the Pleadings.

This unique request differs from a Summary Judgement in that there is a genuine dispute of fact, as well as a Default Judgement in that it's the opinion of the Crown that this case be seen through to the end for fairness.

A Judgement on the Pleadings requests that the presiding officer take into account what has already occurred in this case, and as a trier of fact make a final ruling and determination.

Normally, this wouldn't be needed. Here, I think it is. This is a unique situation where I believe the Court is the only dis-interested party left insofar as it is probably the only one capable of rendering a fair and just verdict without accusations of political shenanigans or chicanery.

If ∴ ⨿🝛 representing the Plaintiff makes a move, people will accuse PM Sir Wigglesworth C. Shimmerclutch and Solicitor General Stephen W. Spooner, Jr. of corruption and collusion. And vice versa for whatever the aforementioned latter of the particular individuals do.


Submitted Respectfully,

∴ ⨿🝛
The Artist Formerly Known as ConsequencesInc
11/04/2026

Your Honor, the Crown does not oppose the entreaty

Respectfully submitted,
bloodyrebals
Minister of Justice
 
The Defendant themself has not responded but it seems the parties agree. Normally, a judgement of the pleadings would be a summary judgement where there is no "genuine dispute of material fact" (Gen. Court R. & Proc. Part V, §2). However, there is a dispute of material fact in this case, meaning a summary judgement cannot apply under this rule. Yet, considering the conflicts all parties have in this case, a judgement of pleadings "is the only reasonable option to protect the integrity and to adhere to the guiding principles of the court" (Gen. Court R. & Proc. Part I, §3(c)). Therefore, the Court accepts this judgement of the pleadings under Gen. Court R. & Proc. Part I, §3(c) and will not accept any briefs on the matter due to the conflicts. The Court now enters recess pending verdict.
 

Verdict


Thritystone v. Crown, Case 6 (Mag. Ct., 2026)

For simplicity of this verdict, Thritystone will be referred to as the Defendant.

I. THE PARTIES’ OPINION​


A. THE CROWN’S OPINION
1. The Defendant unlawfully killed Capt11543, constituting murder.
2. Capt11543 did not consent to the Murder. They were killed trying to apprehend the Defendant.
3. The Defendant tried to flee arrest from PhillinDeBlanc on the same day, constituting Evading or Resisting Arrest.

B. THE DEFENSE’S OPINION

1. The Crown must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the Defendant unlawfully killed Capt11543 & evaded arrest.
2. PhillinDeBlanc did not identify themselves as an officer, making their arrest seem like a vigilante attack.

II. THE COURT’S OPINION​


A. ON ONE COUNT OF MURDER

The Court must assume the arrest was lawful from the evidence provided here today. From the A.P.04-019 | Criminal Procedure Act, rights do not have to be made for an arrest, only an interrogation. No interrogation was recorded in this case, meaning the arrest was valid according to this law.

The question the Court has to decide today is there is a reasonable doubt that the Defendant committed Murder? The Crown has provided the logs from the plugin and a testimony from the victim. The Defense has provided speculation that the victim, who alleged they were killed with an arrow shot, could’ve been killed with more than they saw, questioning if one arrow can kill them with the armor they normally wear. However, neither party has brought up something the Court has noticed: staff intent. There isn’t a direct veto list, but the Court wonders how staff treats the validity of the Homeland plugin. Our neighbor across the pond, Redmont, has a veto on a case, where Staff noted that “[the] Homeland Security plugin is considered presumptively correct as evidence, until proven otherwise by evidence other than witness testimony alone.” Staff affirmed that this veto does apply in Alexandria.

1794972457868.png

This veto thus establishes the burden of proof for the Crown. The Defense must provide other evidence to refute it, which they have failed to do.

B. ON ONE COUNT OF EVADING OR RESISTING ARREST

The Court’s main question when deciding this charge is as follows: is evading or resisting arrest allowed when one reasonably believes that the individual detaining them is not a valid officer? A.P. 04-020 | Criminal Code Act (CCA) §10(3) defines Evading or Resisting Arrest as follows:
(13) Evading or Resisting Arrest - A player is guilty of evading or resisting arrest if they attempt to escape from a peace officer when that peace officer is at that moment attempting to legally arrest or detain them.

So when someone commits Evading or Resisting Arrest under the definition, do they get the charge? No, as they must have a “guilty mind” and “guilty action”, as defined in CCA §2(2):
(2) For a criminal offense to occur, a player must have both a guilty mind and a guilty action. A guilty mind requires a showing that the player acted intentionally, knowingly, willfully, recklessly, or negligently. A guilty action requires showing that through their guilty mind, a player acted in a defined way to commit the criminal offense.

So, if an individual reasonably believed they were escaping a vigilante attack, they should not be charged, as they did not act in a way to commit a criminal offense. So the Court now must decide if the Defendant really believed they were escaping a vigilante attack.

Due to the judgement of the pleadings, we never got to hear from the Defendant. Therefore, the Court must work with the other evidence provided. The first evidence: chatlogs of the Defendant’s escape (P-001). PhillinDeBlanc told the individual to freeze, and that they were under arrest. The Defendant still fled. The next evidence: testimony from the arresting officer that the Defendant fled to the Outback. The final evidence: testimony from the arresting officer that the MoJ issues equipment, like tasers and handcuffs, to peace officers that are not available to the general public.

The Court can look at all the evidence, but cannot make the argument. The Crown has the burden of proof, and must prove to the Court that the Defendant committed Evading or Resisting Arrest with a guilty mind and guilty action. The Crown has failed to prove to the Court that the Defendant had guilty action. The Defendant could have had guilty action, but the Court does see the vigilante belief as a plausible scenario, thus having a reasonable doubt that the Defendant is innocent. Therefore, the Court cannot keep this charge.

Now, for reimbursement. A.P.04-019 | Criminal Procedure Act §9(3) establishes that upon dismissal of a charge “all criminal liability arising from those charges shall be nullified, jail time imposed shall be lifted, and fines paid shall be reimbursed to the defendant in full.” The Court cannot see from the evidence provided which fine actually was attributed to Murder and Escaping or Resisting Arrest, as the Defendant was only charged £600 instead of the maximum of £1200. The Ministry of Justice’s internal records and policy would be better to suit how much the fine should be repaid, instead of the Court ordering a specific number. Finally, for the reimbursement of time spent in jail. As noted, A.P.04-019 §9(3) orders for all jail time imposed to be lifted, but fails to mention how time wrongfully spent in prison should be reimbursed. Surely, time wrongfully spent in prison should be reimbursed? Yet, what should the reimbursement be? The Court sees a valid reimbursement at £100 per minute unlawfully spent in prison, inspired by the settlement in McBrittle419 v. Crown, Case 7 (Mag. Ct., 2026).

The Court also sees that legal fees should be awarded, but wonders what the value should be. The Court looks at the complexity of this case. This case only involved opening statements and limited witness testimony. There were no witnesses from the Defense nor any closing statements. In Plura72 v. Dearev, Case 3 (Mag. Ct., 2025), the Court pointed out how legal fees should change based on complexity and value. Since this case didn’t have Defense witnesses, closing statements, or sentencing, and the Defendant was found guilty on the Murder charge, the Court believes 15% of the case value is a good percentage. Since the fine was £600 pounds, the Court will order 15% of that.

III. DECISION​


On one count of Murder, the Defendant is found GUILTY. The Court sees no reason to decrease the penalty that was already issued.

On one count of Escaping or Resisting Arrest, the Defendant is found NOT GUILTY. The Ministry of Justice shall reimburse the fine for Escaping or Resisting Arrest, reimburse the Defendant £100 per minute spent in prison attributable to the charge of Escaping or Resisting Arrest, and remove the record of Escaping or Resisting Arrest on the Defendant.

The Court also awards the Defendant’s counsel, ConsequencesInc, with £90 in legal fees, payable from the Crown.

The Court thanks all parties for their time and apologizes for this long and drawn out case.

So ordered,
Magistrate Grey Frontier

 
Back
Top